Get up to 2% cashback** redeemed to your personal bank account. Chat with us.

LLC vs Corporation In Wisconsin - 2024

LLC vs Corporation In Wisconsin 2024 Guide

Lisa Shmulyan
Founder 101
February 15, 2024

Understanding LLCs and Corporations

LLCs and corporations are both popular types of business entities in Wisconsin, offering distinct features. LLCs provide flexibility, simplicity, and protection from personal liability. Corporations have a more structured setup with a focus on shareholders and formalities.

Definition and Characteristics of an LLC

A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a business structure that combines the benefits of partnerships and corporations. It provides liability protection, ensuring that personal assets are generally not at risk for business debts.

LLCs are known for their flexible management structures. Owners, called members, can choose to manage the business themselves or appoint managers. This allows for a personalized approach to operations. Additionally, LLCs have fewer record-keeping requirements compared to corporations. They often have simpler tax requirements, as they can opt for pass-through taxation, avoiding double taxation on profits.

The creation of an LLC typically involves filing Articles of Organization with the state. In Wisconsin, all LLCs formed after January 1, 2023, are governed by Wisconsin's New LLC Law, which offers an updated legal framework. The flexibility of an LLC makes it an appealing choice for many small to medium-sized businesses seeking limited liability protection without extensive corporate formalities.

Definition and Characteristics of a Corporation

A corporation is a distinct legal entity separate from its owners, who are called shareholders. It offers strong liability protection, shielding personal assets from business liabilities. Corporations are characterized by a well-defined structure, including a board of directors who oversee the company's direction.

Corporations can issue stock, which allows them to raise capital more easily. They are subject to more regulatory requirements and formalities compared to LLCs. This includes annual meetings, maintaining bylaws, and keeping detailed corporate records. Corporations in Wisconsin are impacted by the New Business Entity Law, which took effect on January 1, 2023.

Corporations may face double taxation, meaning that profits are taxed at both the corporate level and again as personal income when distributed as dividends. Despite this, corporations remain popular among larger businesses seeking investment opportunities and scalability.

Business Formation in Wisconsin

Starting a business in Wisconsin involves deciding between forming a Limited Liability Company (LLC) or incorporating as a corporation. Each option offers distinct benefits and processes to consider, and understanding these can help in making the right choice for the business structure.

Establishing a Wisconsin LLC

Forming a Wisconsin LLC begins with filing the Articles of Organization with the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions. This document outlines basic details about the LLC, such as its name and address. An important aspect of an LLC is the Operating Agreement, which sets out the rights and responsibilities of members and managers. Although not required by law, it's crucial for outlining internal regulations.

Registered Agent: An LLC must also have a registered agent, responsible for receiving legal documents.

Annual Report: Submission of an annual report is mandatory to maintain good standing, usually accompanied by a small fee.

Incorporating a Business in Wisconsin

To incorporate, businesses must file Articles of Incorporation with the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions. This involves providing information similar to what's required for an LLC but also includes details about the number and types of shares being issued.

Corporate Tax: Corporations are subject to a corporate tax, which differs from the tax treatment of LLCs.

A board of directors is established during incorporation, which oversees the company's operations. It's crucial to maintain minutes of board meetings and follow formal corporate governance procedures to comply with state regulations. Businesses should explore incorporating options and requirements in depth on sites like Active Filings, where specifics about the costs and processing times are detailed.

Ownership and Management Structures

In Wisconsin, understanding the distinctions between ownership and management structures in LLCs and corporations is essential for business owners. Both models offer unique benefits and challenges depending on the goals and needs of the business.

Ownership in LLCs and Corporations

In an LLC, ownership is defined by membership interests. Each member holds a share, which can vary based on their contribution. LLCs provide flexibility as members can decide on the percentage of profits and decision-making power without strict adherence to capital investment.

Corporations, on the other hand, have shareholders who own shares of stock. Ownership percentage correlates with the number of shares owned. Corporations can be structured as either S-corporations or C-corporations, affecting tax treatment and shareholder numbers. For more details on Wisconsin LLC law, check out this state bar article.

Management Variations Between LLCs and Corporations

Management in LLCs has two primary structures: member-managed and manager-managed. In a member-managed LLC, all members are involved in decision-making. A manager-managed LLC appoints certain individuals or groups to make decisions, offering a streamlined process for larger organizations.

Corporations typically have a board of directors that oversees major decisions while officers manage daily operations. This separation can help in establishing clear authority and accountability. For further insights on corporations vs LLCs, visit the Wisconsin Business Law Blog.

Tax Considerations and Implications

When deciding between forming an LLC or a corporation in Wisconsin, tax considerations are critical. LLCs often enjoy flexibility in tax classification, while corporations face stricter rules and potential double taxation. Each structure offers unique advantages and obligations.

LLC Taxation in Wisconsin

In Wisconsin, LLCs provide flexible tax options. Owners can opt for pass-through taxation where profits and losses are reported on personal tax returns, avoiding double taxation. Single-member LLCs are typically disregarded entities, meaning they are taxed like sole proprietorships. Multi-member LLCs usually default to partnership taxation. A notable advantage includes potential savings on self-employment taxes since LLC members can elect to be taxed as an S corporation, potentially reducing liability. However, they must address both state and local tax obligations. For example, the City of Milwaukee imposes a 2% sales and use tax as of January 2024, adding to the local tax rates.

Corporation Taxation in Wisconsin

Corporations in Wisconsin encounter more rigid tax structures and potential double taxation. C corporations face a corporate tax rate and must file a separate tax return. This structure allows deductions for salaries and benefits, which can provide tax advantages. The corporate tax rate stands at 21%, impacting the company's taxable income. Conversely, S corporations offer pass-through taxation like LLCs but require stricter eligibility criteria. To maintain compliance, corporations must regularly estimate tax payments. State policies in Wisconsin, such as laws governing corporate taxation mentioned in the Wisconsin Business Law Blog, offer further insights into legal expectations and obligations.

Regulatory Compliance and Responsibilities

In Wisconsin, regulatory compliance for LLCs and corporations centers around maintaining proper fiduciary duties and fulfilling state obligations. This involves ensuring adherence to operational and reporting standards that safeguard the company's integrity and legal standing.

Fiduciary Duties and Operational Requirements

Both LLCs and corporations must adhere to fiduciary duties which include the duty of loyalty, duty of care, and the duty to act in good faith. Directors of corporations are held to stricter standards compared to LLC members. They must prioritize the company’s interests, avoiding conflicts of interest and ensuring all dealings are fair.

LLCs, guided by the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act, have flexibility in operations. Members may define fiduciary duties in the operating agreement. In contrast, corporate directors must abide by state statutes, requiring formal adherence to board decisions and responsibilities.

Compliance Reporting and State Obligations

Corporations in Wisconsin must file annual reports with the State Department, pay franchise taxes, and stick to strict governance protocols. Regular board meetings are necessary, with minutes kept as part of public records. This ensures transparency and accountability.

LLCs are relatively less burdened with formalities but must also submit annual reports and maintain compliance with state laws. Companies created after January 1, 2023, are subject to the new LLC Act. Those formed earlier can choose the framework they wish to follow. This flexibility allows LLCs to maintain operations as per their strategic needs and the preferences outlined in their operating agreements.

Legal Dynamics of LLCs

Wisconsin's LLC laws have seen significant changes, which impact how these business entities are formed and operated. Key aspects include adjustments to governing statutes and the flexibility offered to existing LLCs.

LLC Law and the Revised Statutes

The New LLC Law in Wisconsin incorporates ideas from the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (RULLCA). This update remodels Chapter 183, emphasizing a modern approach that aligns Wisconsin with other states. Newly formed LLCs after January 1, 2023, must adhere to these revised statutes. Existing LLCs can either adopt the new rules by filing a Statement of Applicability or maintain old statutes through a Statement of Non-Applicability. This flexibility allows businesses to choose a structure that best fits their operational needs.

Modifications in the Wisconsin Uniform Limited Liability Company Law

The changes in the Wisconsin Uniform Limited Liability Company Law (WULLCL) provide updates to operating agreements, giving more freedom in defining management and decision-making processes. Members can opt-in to these new provisions, broadening their ability to tailor company rules. Key updates also enable LLCs to restructure governance models without rewriting entire agreements, making it easier to adapt to business needs. The opt-out features offer flexibility, ensuring that businesses are not forced into a one-size-fits-all model. These modifications position Wisconsin as a competitive state for LLC formation.

Alteration and Termination of Business Entities

Alteration and termination of business entities in Wisconsin involve specific processes like dissolution and methods for merging or converting business structures. Understanding these processes is important for business owners to ensure compliance with state regulations.

The Process of Dissolution

Dissolution is the legal act of ending a business's existence. In Wisconsin, this process involves several steps. First, the business must settle all debts and obligations. The members or shareholders must then approve the dissolution by voting, typically according to the operating agreement or corporate bylaws.

After approval, a statement of dissolution must be filed with the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions. This document provides public notice that the entity is no longer in operation, helps protect against future claims, and concludes the business's authority to transact. Proper notice to creditors and timely filing of final tax returns are critical aspects of successful dissolution.

Merger and Conversion Options

Mergers and conversions allow businesses to change their structure or combine with another entity. A merger involves two or more entities pooling their resources and operations, while a conversion allows a business to change its form, such as converting from an LLC to a corporation.

In Wisconsin, businesses must file a plan of merger or plan of conversion with the state. The Wisconsin Uniform Limited Liability Company Law provides guidelines for these processes, including how authority and statements of authority are impacted. Approvals from the company’s stakeholders are typically required for these actions, ensuring all parties adhere to agreements and state laws.

Comparative Analysis

Choosing between an LLC and a corporation in Wisconsin involves understanding the distinctions in legal, tax, and operational characteristics. Considerations include regulatory history, liability protection, and management structure.

Benefits and Limitations of LLCs vs. Corporations

LLCs offer flexibility in management, allowing members to decide how to run the business. There is no maximum number of owners, and profits are passed through, meaning income is only taxed once. This can be more beneficial for small businesses or a sole proprietorship interested in minimizing administrative burdens. However, Wisconsin's new LLC law introduces regulations that provide choices for new governance.

Conversely, corporations have a long legal and regulatory history. This offers more predictability in legal matters, which can be reassuring for investors. Corporations can raise capital by selling shares, making them appealing for companies planning to expand. Ownership is transferable, which is helpful in attracting and retaining investment. The downside is the potential for double taxation, as income can be taxed at both corporate and personal levels.

Decision-Making Factors for Entrepreneurs

Entrepreneurs must weigh several factors when choosing between an LLC and a corporation. Liability protection is crucial; both structures offer limited personal liability, but the corporation's established legal framework may be preferable for businesses with high-risk exposure. Business formation costs and operational complexity also differ; LLCs are generally easier and cheaper to form.

Taxation preferences will also influence the decision. Some may prefer the pass-through taxation of LLCs, while others might accept double taxation for the benefit of attracting investment. Additionally, the formation requirements for corporations can be more stringent, which may appeal to those seeking structural rigor. Entrepreneurs must assess these factors in light of their business goals and future plans.

Legislative Evolution

Wisconsin has undergone significant changes in its business laws, particularly regarding LLCs and corporations. Two major developments include Senate Bill 566, leading to Act 258, and notable advancements in business law.

Senate Bill 566 and Act 258 Implications

The signing of Senate Bill 566, which became Act 258, marked a pivotal change in Wisconsin's business regulations. This Act revamped Chapter 183, adapting the Wisconsin Uniform Limited Liability Company Law to align with national standards, particularly the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (RULLCA). It introduced changes affecting LLC governance, making them more adaptable to modern business needs.

A significant addition under Act 258 is the emphasis on good faith and fair dealing within LLCs, ensuring ethical standards in management and operations. This shift encourages transparency and accountability among LLC members.

Advancements in Business Law

The evolution in Wisconsin's business law landscape extends beyond just LLCs. It encompasses reforms that impact both limited liability companies and corporations. These advancements reflect a trend towards harmonizing state laws with national guidelines. By incorporating features like streamlined filing procedures and updated protection standards, Wisconsin aims to foster a more business-friendly environment.

Advancements in business law have also led to clearer distinctions between LLCs and corporations, aiding business owners in choosing the right structure. This clarity is particularly beneficial for startups and entrepreneurs who can now better understand the implications of their choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Choosing between an LLC and a corporation in Wisconsin involves understanding various benefits, tax differences, and initial costs. Legal obligations and operational differences further highlight the choice that best suits an individual's business needs.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of establishing an LLC versus a corporation in Wisconsin?

LLCs offer flexibility and simpler management structures. They also have fewer formalities. Meanwhile, corporations benefit from established legal frameworks, potentially providing more straightforward paths for raising capital. Consider how Wisconsin's New LLC Law impacts these structures and choose based on long-term goals and operational preferences.

How do the tax implications differ between an LLC and a corporation in Wisconsin?

An LLC typically offers pass-through taxation, meaning the profits are taxed once on the personal income of the owners. Corporations face double taxation, where profits are taxed at both the corporate and personal levels. The DFI Business Entity FAQ provides more guidance on choosing the right structure for your taxation needs.

What are the initial and ongoing costs associated with forming an LLC compared to a corporation in Wisconsin?

Initial filing fees for an LLC are generally lower than for a corporation. However, both entities require annual filing fees. LLCs might incur fewer administrative expenses over time. The Forbes guide on starting an LLC in Wisconsin can be useful for estimating costs.

What are the legal requirements for an LLC to file taxes in Wisconsin?

LLCs must file an annual report with the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions. Those classified as corporations for tax must file a corporate tax return. Partnerships file informational returns. Accurate records and timely filings are crucial for compliance.

How does operating as a sole proprietorship differ from an LLC in Wisconsin?

A sole proprietorship is easy to form and maintain but lacks liability protection. An LLC provides legal separation between personal and business assets, safeguarding the owner from debts and liabilities. The Wisconsin Business Law Blog highlights these differences further.

What are the reasons one might choose to form a corporation over an LLC?

Corporations may attract investors more easily due to their structured nature and established rules. They offer stock options, making them attractive to potential shareholders. If a business plans to expand rapidly or go public, a corporation might be more suitable.

Meet Every, bookkeeping & taxes for startups and entrepreneurs

Contact our team for tailored advice & assistance

Subscribe to get founder advice delivered straight to your inbox.